Skeptoid PodcastSkeptoid on Facebook   Skeptoid on Twitter   Skeptoid on Stitcher   iTunes   Google Play

Members Portal

Store

 

Get a Free Book

 

SKEPTOID BLOG:

Common Myths About Space - Revealed

by Dani Johnson

January 18, 2013

Share Tweet Reddit

Donate I can remember being fascinated with space ever since I was a very young child. The first thing I did when we got our elementary school science text books was flip to the part about the planets so I could make sure that I had something to look forward to during class. This is no secret to the people I know and I am often the one that gets a text message or an email when someone has a question or hears about something really cool —or really outrageous and hopefully not true- that is supposed to happen.

I would say I am surprised at how easily false assumptions or misinterpreted information can be spread as "truth" but it is so easy to innocently pass on something interesting and simply assume that the person who gave you the information wouldn't pass it along if it weren't true - even if you don't even know the person because you found it online. It's so easy to assume responsibility onto another person to avoid the trouble of having to look up information before one passes something false to another person. Personally, I am a research junky and I really enjoy looking up information and learning new things even if they seem small or irrelevant. In the following examples it's definitely obvious that reality is actually more interesting than any myth.

The Myth: Mars will be as big as the full Moon during opposition.


It has been said that if you gaze at the night sky during Mars' opposition you can spot the lovely red planet posing as large as the full Moon herself. It is apparently a once-in-a-lifetime event that you don't want to miss. This comes up every single year and, without much surprise and without even a second thought, never holds to the truth. No one has nor ever will see Mars as large as the full Moon in the night sky from our lands (or sea) here on Earth.


This image was taken within minutes of Mars' closest approach to Earth in 60,000 years, on Aug. 27, 2003. In this picture, the red planet is 34,647,420 miles (55,757,930 km) from Earth.

Credit: NASA, J. Bell (Cornell U.) and M. Wolff (SSI)

Reality: This rumor was started by a chain email that began circulating in 2003 when Earth and Mars were at a record-breaking close distance of only about 56 million kilometers apart. Even then Mars was still 75 times smaller to the naked eye than the full Moon and that's pretty close considering that when the planets are at their farthest they are about 401 million kilometers apart. That's more than seven times as far!

When Mars is in opposition it is in the opposite side of the sky as the Sun as viewed from Earth. This means that the Sun, the Earth and Mars form a straight line with Earth sandwiched in the middle. When planets are in opposition to the Earth they are at their closest to one another.



Two famous rumors (among many others) are that Mars' opposition is an extremely rare occurrence that won't happen again in this lifetime and it will look as large as the full moon in the sky. The only way to truly see the red planet that large would be to travel to her dusty plains one's self and she glides into opposition with the Earth about every two years.

Shortly before the 2003 astronomical event the public began receiving and forwarding a pesky chain email that haphazardly stated that "Mars will look as large as the full Moon if you magnify it 75x using a backyard telescope." and more often than not the second half of the sentence was even separated from the first part and people never paid it any attention. It seems that people are too quick to forget that they live in an age of information and finding the truth to any bogus claim is as simple as typing a question into a search bar. That aside, while Mars was actually 75 times smaller than the full Moon in the sky it still doesn't quite equate to the hypothesis that viewing it magnified that many times would look even close to how the full Moon looks to the naked eye in the sky.

"A good reference is the Moon Illusion. Moons on the horizon look huge; Moons directly overhead look smaller. In both cases, it is the same Moon, but the human mind perceives the size of the Moon differently depending on its surroundings." says Dr. Tony Phillips in Return of the Mars Hoax.

The same concept applies to Mars, and when one is viewing it through the long, dark barrel of a telescope it is going to look much tinier than the full Moon regardless of magnification strength.

The Myth: Meteors are falling stars.


Anyone who has ever seen a meteor knows that it was probably just a star falling from its perch up there in the sky. I mean, they are about the same size as stars — sometimes much bigger- so they have to be stars, right? Not so much.



A Storm of Meteors in 1999 Credit: NASA This image was taken during the 1999 Leonid meteor storm as part of NASA's Leonid Multi-Instrument Aircraft Campaign (Leonid MAC). The image was captured with a 28 mm camera.



Reality: Meteors are caused when tiny particles left over by comets and asteroids combust upon entering our atmosphere. Comets are continually losing matter that forms river of particles that follow its eccentric orbit around the sun. The Earth is also orbiting the Sun and its orbit passes through that of the comet and these left over particles slam into our atmosphere and dazzle the world. Most of the time these particles burn up completely before ever reaching the ground but on the very rare occasion that the meteor was big enough to survive the plummet we call them meteorites and they are incredibly valuable to science because we can study the composition of the comet or asteroid that is known to produce that particular shower.

The Myth: The Great Wall of China is the only man-made object visible from the Moon.


Long before man even stepped foot on the Moon it has been boasted that The Great Wall of China would be visible from its surface with just the naked eye. But it was all really just speculative hype until we were able to take a look from the surface of the moon ourselves.



This photo of central Inner Mongolia, about 200 miles north of Beijing, was taken on Nov. 24, 2004, from the International Space Station. The yellow arrow points to an estimated location of 42.5N 117.4E where the wall is visible. The red arrows point to other visible sections of the wall. Credit: NASA.

Reality: It turns out that from about 237,000 miles away,

"The only thing you can see from the Moon is a beautiful sphere, mostly white (clouds), some blue (ocean), patches of yellow (deserts), and every once in a while some green vegetation. No man-made object is visible on this scale. In fact, when first leaving Earth's orbit and only a few thousand miles away, no man-made object is visible at that point either." says Apollo 12 Astronaut Alan Bean.



Taken by Apollo 8 crew member Bill Anders on December 24, 1968, showing the Earth seemingly rising above the lunar surface. Note that this phenomenon is only visible from someone in orbit around the Moon. Because of the Moon's synchronous rotation about the Earth (i.e., the same side of the Moon is always facing the Earth), no Earthrise can be observed by a stationary observer on the surface of the Moon.

The myth has since generalized into saying that the wall is visible "from space" and usually doesn't specify whether it means visible with the naked eye nor does it specify how far out in space we are looking from. Even assuming that it means through the naked eye and from low-Earth orbit, the wall is made of material that is a similar color and texture to the surrounding land and it is barely discernible if not downright invisible. Oh, and other man-made objects are definitely visible from space.

If you're also interested in making sure the facts about any myth are readily available for you to reference in a debate, you can start by helping the skeptic community take measure to ensure scientific quality and skepticism on Wikipedia. Check out Susan Gerbic's blog Guerrilla Skepticism on Wikipedia.

Sources:


Opposition (Planets) - Wikipedia

Approaching Mars - Science@NASA

Beware the Mars Hoax - Science@NASA

Return of the Mars Hoax - Science@NASA

The Mutating Mars Hoax - Science@NASA

Mars Will Look as Big as the Full Moon - Astronomy.com

Mars Spectacular - Snopes

China's Wall Less Great View From Space - NASA

Is China's Great Wall Visible from Space? - Scientific American

Great Walls of Liar - Snopes

Alan Bean - NASA

Man-Made Structures Visible From Space - Wikipedia

Picture Album: Hubble's Closest View of Mars -- August 27, 2003 - Hubblesite

Most Amazing Leonid Meteor Shower Photos - Space.com

Do Stars Move? - Universe Today

How Meteor Showers Work (Infographic)

Earthrise (image) - Wikipedia

Further Reading:


Astronomy: Why is a Harvest Moon So Large? - astro.wsu.edu

Meteor Showers and Shooting Stars: Formation, Facts and Discovery -Space.com

by Dani Johnson

Share Tweet Reddit

@Skeptoid Media, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit

 

 

 

Donate