The Vanishing Village of Angikuni Lake

Did the population of a remote Eskimo village completely disappear in 1930?

by Brian Dunning

Filed under Aliens & UFOs, History & Pseudohistory, Urban Legends

Skeptoid #371
July 16, 2013
Podcast transcript | Listen | Subscribe
 

The year was 1930; the place, the frozen wastes of northern Canada. It was November, late fall, and the flat landscape was blasted over with ice crystals and wind. A lone trapper, Joe Labelle, made his way to an Inuit village he knew. All looked well as he approached; but when he arrived, nobody answered his greeting calls. Labelle looked around and found everything in place, everything except the people — the entire population of the village had vanished. Food, clothing, rifles, half-cooked meals, and everything else needed for life on the tundra were all at the ready, but no Inuit to use them. Labelle stood on the shore of Angikuni Lake and pondered the mystery, then went straight away and reported the disappearance to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Since then, the story of Angikuni Lake has been a mainstay of Canadian mystery lore.

You'd hardly recognize Angikuni Lake as a lake. Nunavut is the largest and northernmost of Canada's territories, and is one of the most sparsely populated regions on Earth. There are more than 50 square kilometers of barren rock and ice per person in Nunavut — half the density of Greenland, and most of them speak Inuktitut. There is only major settlement within the whole of this vast territory, the capital Iqaluit with less than 7,000 population, 1500 kilometers east of Angikuni Lake. Nunavut encloses most of the Canadian Arctic Archipelago and its mainland portion is almost completely devoid of any features at all, having been scraped flat by glaciers that left only barren rock and tundra laced with shallow puddles and streams, generously called lakes and rivers. A few dozen of these puddles, loosely linked together, are what comprise Angikuni Lake. During most of the year it's an unbroken flat plain of ice and snow, completely indistinct from anything within 500 kilometers in any direction. They call this part of Canada the Barren Grounds.

The most famous published account of Joe Labelle's mysterious encounter comes from Frank Edwards' 1959 book Stranger than Science, in which Edwards devoted three short pages to the story. He tells how the Mounted Police returned to the village site with Labelle and confirmed everything he told them. And like Labelle, they were unable to find any trace of the villagers, nor come up with any suggestion why they might have left all of their valuables and necessities behind. Their kayaks still sat on the beach, meals still hung over long-dead cooking fires. The police also found the frozen bodies of the villagers' dogs. Edwards' chapter concludes:

Months of patient and far-flung investigation failed to produce a single trace of any member who had lived in the deserted village of Anjikuni. The Mounted Police filed it as unsolved... and so it remains.

There are a number of things about the Joe Labelle story that raise red flags. For one thing, it happened in November, when average temperatures are 13°C degrees below freezing. Angikuni Lake is a sheet of ice; kayaks pulled up on the beach would not be "battered by wave action". The very presence of kayaks so far inland is suspect, though not impossible. Migratory Inuit would often portage their kayaks to hunt caribou. These eastern Iglulik kayaks were made of sealskin stretched over willow branches. But the small Angikuni Lake is landlocked so far inland on the Barrens that neither willow nor sealskin were available, and this would be by far the farthest inland that the historical use of Iglulik kayaks would have ever been documented. Not impossible, but highly suspect.

Edwards also had Labelle describing a permanent settlement, a "friendly little Eskimo village" of "about thirty inhabitants" that he'd known "for many years". A statement from the Mounted Police says "A village with such a large population would not have existed in such a remote area of the Northwest Territories." They had left sealskin garments behind, in a region where there was caribou hide rather than sealskin; and as a trapper Labelle should have been able to identify it properly. So there was either a series of quite improbable circumstances, or Labelle was wrong, or Edwards was wrong.

Today, no physical evidence exists of a village at Angikuni Lake, and nobody has ever published an account of going up there and clearing away any remnants. So we have to rely on documentary evidence to find the true history of the vanishing village.

Interestingly, following the history of the published accounts is a bit like trying to follow one of those movies that's out of sequence and jumps around from different time periods; and you'll see what I mean.

The earliest recorded publication about Angikuni Lake is a 1976 citation of an article from November 29, 1930, written by an Emmett E. Kelleher in the Halifax Herald newspaper. Kelleher, writing as a "special correspondent" for the paper, told Labelle's story and gave the village a population of 25, and offered a more reserved version of the artifacts Labelle found including a single rusty old rifle and a few dog corpses. The article included a generic photograph of an Inuit village.

Next, on January 17 of 1931, Cortland Starnes, the Commissioner of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, released an investigation of the event undertaken by a Sergeant J. Nelson. Nelson, in speaking with local traders, learned that Joe Labelle was a real person but worked only in northern Manitoba. He also discovered that Kelleher's photograph was an old one from the RCMP's own archives, and as nobody in the region had heard of this village or its disappearance, Nelson concluded the entire episode was a sensationalized hoax made up by Kelleher.

For the next 28 years, it appears that the presses were quiet. I was able to find no printed works at all, of any kind, that mentioned Angikuni Lake or any of the names involved; until 1959 when Frank Edwards' book was released. Edwards slightly increased the number of Inuit from 25 to 30. Edwards offered no sources for his chapter, and did not mention the alleged 1930 or 1931 releases.

Over the next 17 years, the presses were almost as quiet. A few scattered references to Edwards' version of the story appeared in books about psychics and the paranormal, but no new details were introduced.

It was 1976 when the story really broke. Dwight Whalen wrote a cover story for the November 1976 issue of FATE Magazine called "Vanished Village Revisited". Whalen was the first to note the 1930 and 1931 articles, there does not seem to be any record of any earlier author finding them. Whalen also wrote that when he called the RCMP personally, he was told they had no record of any such event — despite the many details in Sgt. Nelson's report, provided by the RCMP Commissioner himself. Whalen concluded that the whole story was largely invented by Emmet Kelleher, possibly based on a tall tale he heard from Joe Labelle who may, or may not, have stumbled on some actual ruins of a village or camp.

And then things got weird. In the April 1977 edition of FATE, a reader wrote in to dispute Whalen's conclusion. This reader was none other than Betty Hill, at the time the most famous self-described alien abductee in the world, and subject of the 1966 book The Interrupted Journey: Two Lost Hours Aboard a Flying Saucer. Betty claimed that while on a ferry ride with her husband Barney at the Bay of Fundy, they met a Captain Larsen who, as a Mountie, had spent nine years investigating the mystery of the vanishing village at Angikuni Lake. In his opinion, wrote Betty, the villagers had all been abducted by UFOs.

From this point on, UFO writers everywhere began including Angikuni Lake in their books. The 1983 book The World's Great UFO Mysteries by Nigel Blundell and Roger Boar amplified the population of the village to 1200, and added the element of three trappers, Armand Laurent and his two sons, seeing UFOs flying toward Angikuni. They then encountered a group of Mounties on their way to investigate the flying objects. In this version of the story, Joe Labelle used a telegraph to report the vanished village, despite there being no telegraphs within probably a thousand kilometers of the lake.

In 1988 John Colombo's book Mysterious Canada repeated all of this, including Blundell and Boar's overblown details and all of Whalen's correspondence with the RCMP. People magazine ran a 1988 article essentially repeating all of this sensationalized new information. The Canadian UFO Report published in 2006 by Rutkowski and Dittman added all the villagers' ancestral graves having been emptied, and a Rense.com article in 2001 increased the village population to 2000 and buried the dog corpses under twelve feet of snow.

What is a fact-hunting researcher to do?

Going back to the original sources is sometimes easier said than done. Whalen gave precise details of the publication of the 1930 newspaper article and the 1931 RCMP report, and — according to researcher Patrick Derksen who worked with the staff at the Millennium Library in Winnipeg in 2013 — neither appears to exist. They also searched all other Manitoba newspapers from the day, and found no references to the story whatsoever, nor any record of an Emmett E. Kelleher. Certainly nothing like it appears in the microfilm copies I have on my desk right now.

$2/mo $5/mo $10/mo One time

Update! The original 1930 report has been found, in an article in "The Bee" from Danville, Virginia, not in Manitoba. The conclusion of this episode will be updated as soon as I can get around to it.

In 1988, the Australian Skeptics contacted the RCMP historian, S. W. Horrall, who wrote:

Many years ago the members (of RCMP), then retired, who had served in the area at the time these events were purported to have happened (1930) were asked for their comments on the story. They could not confirm it, recalled nothing like it, and were astounded that such a ridiculous tale could be believed. Our files were carefully searched. No strange craft was ever reported. No one named Joe Labelle ever came to the RCMP in panic about Lake Anjikuni. The RCMP did not send out any search parties. The only records we have on the story are copies of letters to correspondents like yourself informing the writers that the story is entirely fictitious.

It seems clear that Frank Edwards' 1959 chapter is indeed the genesis of the tale, apparently made up from whole cloth. It also seems clear that Dwight Whalen, writing in 1976 some 45 years after the event, took advantage of the fact the no one who would have been involved was still living, and invented both the 1930 newspaper article and the 1931 RCMP report (if I'm wrong about this, I warmly invite proof to the contrary). These fabricated reports provided the seeds of a story that motivated UFO writers for decades to come.

Could Frank Edwards have ever imagined how his little campfire tale of a lonely trapper finding a mysteriously abandoned village would have grown? It grew largely due to citations of fake newspaper articles. Back in the fifties and even the seventies, the state of archiving technology might have made it possible for unscrupulous writers to get away with that. Today they still can, but only when their readers accept secondary and tertiary sources without scrutiny — which is, unfortunately, the case all too often.

Please see the update above. Though Kelleher's story remains as dubious as ever, it does indeed exist, and Edwards was not the originator of the tale.

Brian Dunning

© 2013 Skeptoid Media, Inc. Copyright information

References & Further Reading

Colombo, J. Ghost Stories of Canada. Toronto: Hounslow, 2000. 200-205.

Editors. "Space Terrorists." The Skeptic. 1 Sep. 1987, Volume 7, Number 4.

Edwards, F. Stranger Than Science. New York: L. Stuart, 1959. 34-36.

RCMP. "Anjikuni." History. Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 24 Jan. 2005. Web. 13 Jul. 2013. <http://www.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/hist/anjikuni-eng.htm>

Wagner, S. "Vanished - Strange Cases of Unsolved Disappearances." Rense.com. Jeff Rense, 18 Jun. 2001. Web. 10 Jul. 2013. <http://rense.com/general11/dis.htm>

Whalen, D. "Vanished Village Revisited." FATE. 1 Nov. 1976, November 1976.

Reference this article:
Dunning, B. "The Vanishing Village of Angikuni Lake." Skeptoid Podcast. Skeptoid Media, Inc., 16 Jul 2013. Web. 19 Aug 2014. <http://skeptoid.com/episodes/4371>

Discuss!

10 most recent comments | Show all 32 comments

The Mounties are hiding the facts! They are in the pocket of the Reptillians.

John Titor, Here
July 24, 2013 11:20am

Clearly, Men in Black went to Manitoba and destroyed all journalistic evidence. Brian, did you check to see if ANY newspapers from January 1930 survive there?

Abby, Austin
July 31, 2013 9:47am

I can't believe that skeptoid has about 11 thousand friends on facebook and every feline-looking quack has over 50 thousand. Come on people..

Yanis K., Greece
August 9, 2013 1:59am

What I find most interesting is that the account that introduced the fake news items is also one that concluded that it did not happen.

However, some years ago I visited the McManus Museum in Dundee, Scotland they had a number of artifacts recovered by the crew of a whaling ship from an Inuit village where the inhabitants had succumbed to starvation. I can easily see a story of this kind being 'twisted' into a village being found with the inhabitents vanished.

Linked below one of the artifacts from the Mcmanus.

http://www.mcmanus.co.uk/content/collections/database/childs-bow-and-arrow

Graham, Australia
September 23, 2013 7:08pm

Someone updating the article on the story for wikipedia stumbled across a website which has what is allegedly a copy of the 1930 version of the story

http://newspaperarchive.com/danville-bee/1930-11-27/page-7

Might be worth searching other US newspapers to see if the story spread.

Graham, Australia
September 24, 2013 10:23am

This is awesome! Clearly an update is needed to my conclusion. I'll do that as soon as I can. Kudos to them for finding this -- I couldn't!

Brian Dunning, Laguna Niguel, CA
September 24, 2013 11:04am

I'd recommend Brian contact the newspaper archive owners and confirm the source of the scan they are hosting. As a gamer I know just how easy it can be to make convincing newspaper props.

This is one case where tracking it down to a physical source could be crucial.

From the looks of the scan the article may have been spread by a wire service.

Graham, Australia
September 24, 2013 7:40pm

I just want to say I LOVE Frank Edwards' books, and wish I could find more. Very entertaining reading.
He's right up there with Arthur Machen, MR James, EF Benson, HP Lovecraft, Joseph Payne Brennan, and and Dean R Koontz.

Ron, Calgary Alberta Canada
January 17, 2014 11:23am

Hello Mr Brian.

Is there any updates about this story?

What I find interesting is what for Whalen made a fake newspaper articles if he concluded that the story never actually happened?

Greggo, Poland
April 29, 2014 6:22am

I like to keep an open mind about these sort of things if I must be honest - what I'm doing on a website made by skeptics / for skeptics I don't know.

Anyway does no one here actually think this might be true. I mean there are other stories about missing people being taken away by Aliens - so why can't this be true? -

It's like what would you do if you was a bunch of Ultra or Extra Terrestrials looking to harvest human organs, DNA etc. Take just 1 person or a whole village of 25 people in the middle of nowhere? because logically it was only be chance Labelle came to this village when he did.

You might think where is the proof - there's no evidence - no confirmation - only one mans word.

My opinion - somebody paid off the mounties to keep quiet - it's a conspiracy there you have it.

John, England
May 22, 2014 12:16pm

Make a comment about this episode of Skeptoid (please try to keep it brief & to the point).

Post a reply

 

What's the most important thing about Skeptoid?

Support Skeptoid
 
Skeptoid host, Brian Dunning
Skeptoid is hosted
and produced by
Brian Dunning


Newest
The Haunted Dybbuk Box
Skeptoid #428, Aug 19 2014
Read | Listen (11:26)
 
The Legend of the Flying Dutchman
Skeptoid #427, Aug 12 2014
Read | Listen (11:49)
 
The Baldoon Mystery
Skeptoid #426, Aug 5 2014
Read | Listen (11:44)
 
Listeners Have Another Say
Aug 1 2014
Listen (4:42)
 
Albino Facts and Fiction
Skeptoid #425, Jul 29 2014
Read | Listen (13:49)
 
Newest
#1 -
The JFK Assassination
Read | Listen
#2 -
Asking the Socratic Questions
Read | Listen
#3 -
5 False Arguments for Raw Milk
Read | Listen
#4 -
Fukushima vs Chernobyl vs Three Mile Island
Read | Listen
#5 -
The Riddle of the L-8 Blimp
Read | Listen
#6 -
Who Discovered the New World?
Read | Listen
#7 -
6 Problems with Wind Turbine Syndrome
Read | Listen
#8 -
An Enthusiast's Primer on Study Types
Read | Listen

Recent Comments...

[Valid RSS]

  Skeptoid PodcastSkeptoid on Facebook   Skeptoid on Twitter   Brian Dunning on Google+   Skeptoid on Stitcher   Skeptoid RSS

Members Portal

 
 


Follow @BrianDunning

Tweets about "skeptoid"

Support Skeptoid

Name/Nickname:  
City/Location:
Email: [Why do we need this?]To reduce spam, we email new faces a confirmation link you must click before your comment will appear.
Comment:
characters left. Abusive posts and spam will be deleted.