Skeptoid: Critical Analysis Podcast 
About This Podcast
Subscribe
Subscribe to the Podcast
Episode Guide
Skeptoid Forum
Hosted by JREF
Skeptalk
Email Discussion List
Search:
What Is Skepticism?
Swag & Crap
One Million Dollar Paranormal Challenge
Videos
Appearances
What People Are Saying...
Press Room
Contact
Subscribe with iTunes
Twitter
Skeptoid on MySpace Facebook

Time travel combined with medical treatment!

- Reflexology: Only Dangerous If You Use It
Recent Comments...

Super Sized Fast Food Phobia
by Max: "I got a definition of artifical vs. natural for you. Are you ready? Natural is food we evolved eating, or food that passed the test…"

SUV Phobia
by N Ring: "Sure I agree with a few of your points but ultimatly I think this is a document written to be skeptical for skeptic sake. …"

What You Didn't Know about the Stanford Prison Experiment
by N Ring: "Ironic that you are asking individuals to be skeptical about a book/professor/experiment that is skeptical. Indeed all scientists go in with a particular bias when…"

An Evolution Primer for Creationists
by neil griffiths: "Yeah! That's why it's called "MYTH"#2! Fr om the works of Darwin Himself-p419-"It is well known that several animals...which inhabit caves of Styria and Kentucky, are…"

Blood for Oil
by Damien: "I am not sure if someone has already made this point, but oil is a fungible comodity. Therefore it does not matter who one's suppliers are…"

Subliminal Seduction
by George Gillan: "New research that might bear on the subject: http://www.ni da.nih.gov/newsroom/08/NR 1-29.html Title: &q uot; Does the Desire for Drugs Begin Outside Awareness? For Release January 29, 2008 NIDA Research Reveals…"

Skeptoid

Chemtrails - Death from the Heavens!

Skeptoid #27
February 15, 2007
Podcast transcript | Listen | Subscribe

Stumble This
Share on Facebook

Today we're going to put on our Men In Black suits, buy a plane ticket, and spray the world with mysterious chemicals as part of an evil government conspiracy. For today's subject is chemtrails.

Wow. Where to begin. I read a fair amount of skeptical, paranormal, and conspiracy web sites, but I don't recall ever reading so much vituperation, anger, and name calling as when I read a few forums discussing chemtrails. If you're not familiar with the term, chemtrails are what some conspiracy theorists call aircraft condensation trails. Most of them don't believe that conventional contrails exist, and that when you see one, you're actually seeing a trail of mysterious airborne chemicals sprayed from the aircraft. Those who do concede the existence of contrails often claim subtle differences in appearance or behavior between a condensation trail and a chemical trail.

First, let's discuss exactly what a contrail is. A condensation trail, also called a vapor trail, forms at altitudes above 25,000 feet in temperatures below -40 degrees when engine exhaust condenses into ice crystals, creating an artificial cirrus cloud. Water is produced by hydrocarbon burning engines in about the same quantity as fuel consumed, and in the right conditions, this extra addition of water into the air pushes the water vapor past the saturation point, and condensation occurs. It takes a moment to happen, which accounts for the contrail appearing a short distance behind the aircraft, rather than immediately, like you'd see from a smoke pod on an aerobatic plane, or like when a crop duster releases chemicals. Contrails can also be caused at high altitudes by the extreme low pressure areas created by wingtip vortices, which reduce the temperature enough to condense the existing moisture in the air. As previously mentioned, many chemtrail believers claim that there is no such thing as a condensation trail. Since they're well understood, 100% reproducible, and observable practically any time you look into the sky, the onus is really on the believers to prove that no such thing is possible. In my opinion they have quite an uphill battle on this one.

By the way, in case you're wondering whether I meant Celsius or Fahrenheit when I said -40 degrees, here's a bit of science trivia for you. -40 is the point where the Celsius and Fahrenheit scales are the same. If you can figure out where Fahrenheit and Kelvins intersect, go to Skeptoid.com and post it in the forum.

Some chemtrail believers say that the population is being gassed with some unknown chemical for an unknown reason. Others tie into pop culture, suggesting that chemtrails are the active manifestation of one proposal to combat global warming by placing dust into the upper atmosphere to reflect sunlight. One guy told me "You guys are so full of yourselves just can't conceive of spiritual warfare can you? Try this fact: malevolent interdimensional entities are involved — project keep the human slave race suppressed."

Like all conspiracy theories, chemtrails require us to accept the existence of a coverup of mammoth proportions. In this case, virtually every aircraft maintenance worker at every airport in the world needs to be either part of the conspiracy, or living under a threat from Men in Black, with not a single whistle blower or deathbed confession in decades. Yet the threats are not frightening enough to prevent stories like the following from appearing on the Internet:

For reasons you will understand as you read this I can not divulge my identity. I am an aircraft mechanic for a major airline. I work at one of our maintenance bases located at a large airport. One day last month I was called out from our base to work on a plane for another airline. When I got to the plane I found out that the problem was in waste disposal system. When I got into the bay I realized that something was not right. There were more tanks, pumps, and pipes then should have been there. As I tried to find the problem I quickly realized the extra piping and tanks were not connected to the waste disposal system, at all. To my amazement the manuals did not show any of the extra equipment I had seen with my own eyes. I even tied in to the manufacturer files and still found nothing. I could trace the control wires from the box to the pumps and valves but there were no control circuits coming into the unit. The only wires coming into the unit was a power connection to the aircraft's main power bus. The system had 1 large tank and 2 smaller tanks. It was hard to tell in the cramped compartment, but it looked like the large tank could hold about 50 gallons. The tanks were connected to a fill and drain valve that passed through the fuselage just behind the drain valve for the waste system. I discovered that the pipes from this mystery system lead to every 1 out of 3 of the static discharge wicks. These wicks had been "hollowed out" to allow whatever flows through these pipes to be discharged through the fake wicks.

About 30 minutes later I was paged to see the General Manager. When I went in his office I found that our union rep and two others who I did not know were waiting on me. He told me that a serious problem had been discovered. He said that I was being written up and suspended for turning in false paperwork. I sat at home the first day of my suspension wondering what the hell had happened to me. That evening I received a phone call. The voice told me "Now you know what happens to mechanics who poke around in things they shouldn't. The next time you start working on systems that are no concern of yours you will lose your job! As it is, I'm feeling generous, I believe that you'll be able to go back to work soon." CLICK. Well that's it. Now I know 'THEY' are watching me.

Another forum poster replied:

I, too, work for an airline, though I work in upper management levels. I wish I could document everything I am about to relate to you, but to do so is next to impossible and would result in possible physical harm to me. Airline companies in America have been participating in something called Project Cloverleaf for a few years now. The earliest date anyone remembers being briefed on it is 1998. I was briefed on it in 1999. The few airline employees who were briefed on Project Cloverleaf were all made to undergo background checks, and before we were briefed on it we were made to sign non-disclosure agreements, which basically state that if we tell anyone what we know we could be imprisoned. About twenty employees in our office were briefed along with me by two officials from some government agency. They didn't tell us which one. They told us that the government was going to pay our airline, along with others, to release special chemicals from commercial aircraft. When asked what the chemicals were and why we were going to spray them, they told us that information was given on a need-to-know basis and we weren't cleared for it. He seemed perturbed at this question and told us in a tone of authority that the public doesn't need to know what's going on, but that this program is in their best interests. He also stated that we should not tell anyone, nor ask any more questions about it.

I take back my comment about the lack of whistle blowers. It seems that just about everyone is discussing it freely, and since the government is openly laying out virtually all the essential details to 20 people in every airline office in the world with complicity from all the union reps, why the secrecy? If we're truly on the edge of a global warming catastrophe and a worldwide cooperative effort to spray reflective dust into the atmosphere is the only way we can save ourselves, wouldn't a little glasnost be a more effective approach? Of course it would, but then we wouldn't have had those two very exciting and original stories.

If the goal was to drug a population, you'd put the gas where it could reach people, you wouldn't release a minute quantity into the jet stream where it's going to be diluted to undetectable levels and eventually rain into the oceans. If the goal is to put reflective dust into the atmosphere to fight global warming, you'd need to plant it a lot higher than commercial jets can travel if you don't want it to rain right back to earth (in fact you need to put it well up into the stratosphere, not just at the top of the troposphere), and you'd need a lot more than can ever be delivered with 50 gallon tanks. But then, the arguments in favor of chemtrails don't appear to be based on any kind of logic. They appear to be based on nothing more than imagined conspiracies and sightings of visible contrails, which are well understood, and are being left by planes every hour of the day over every city in the world, and have been for over 50 years. It's how the malevolent interdimensional entities remind us of their ominous presence.

Stumble This

Brian Dunning
Brian Dunning

References
© 2008 Skeptoid.com

Discuss!

5 most recent comments | Show all 25 comments

Remember, you should always read with skepticism the comments of anyone too lame to put their real name & city.

Let me put my Rose colored glasses on so I can see what you see. Ah yes, a government that is just too honest and trust worthy to get involved in an shinanigans like but not limited to: Sex scandals, money laundering, assasination, false-flag ops the world over and oh yeah, election fraud, I love the hanging Chads, their my favorite band!

If Chemtrails are for real, Nostrodamus has an interesting line about the seventh month of 1999. Something coming down from the sky, I forget.

Beam me up!

Mork From Ork, Ork
February 03, 2008 9:21pm

S. 1807: Weather Mitigation Research and Development Policy Authorization Act of 2007

H.R. 3445: Weather Mitigation Research and Technology Transfer Authorization Act of 2007

Unimpressed, Texas
March 16, 2008 3:26pm

We all saw the chemtrails today up near Newcastle, North/East coast of Australia. A group of us saw an aircraft at 11am spraying vapours, then again in same spot at 5pm. The sky was full of them, and they were very different and distinguishably different to the clouds, we saw it all unfold over a whole day watching. Interestingtly a thunderstorm came tonight, but unusually very little rain, so we assume they are keen to spray before the storm, to prevent the rain, to keep us in a drought.

Here ... check out what the German Meteorologists are doing about chemtrails http://www.opednews.com/articles/genera_the_last_080224_germany_becomes_the _.htm

Sam, Sydney
March 24, 2008 7:17am

I'm currently engaged in a lively debate in just this topic. It's caused by a photo I took and posted to Flickr.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/teamdroid/2433520466/
I'm looking forward to his reply.
Keep up the good work.
-John K.

John K, Phoenix, Az
May 17, 2008 6:05pm

I'm sorry, all these people blathering about 'chemtrails': Which is the scenario which requires the least assumptions (i.e. the simplest):

1) Trails left behind planes are a result of a well-documented and understood phenomenon that you can have explained in your garden variety science textbook

2) "They" are engaging in a massive secret program to do something (something being mind-control, droughts, weather mitigation, whatever). This program is secret enough to make sure no one comes out with any actual evidence of it, but the same "they" apparently don't care if people post 'firsthand' accounts on the internet.

Consider: if the government really wanted to test weather mitigation, or other ominous sounding things, don't you think they could use the 15% of US land occupied by the government (much of which is a no-fly zone)? Don't you think they could, I don't know, use planes for that specific purpose? Do you really think they're going around to commuter airlines and engaging in this nonsense?

Seriously, I know you're afraid of immunization shots, but you need to get a booster shot against paranoia.

eric thorn, Seoul, ROK
June 21, 2008 11:21am

Make a comment about this episode of Skeptoid (please try to keep it brief & to the point). Anyone can post:

Your Name:
City/Location:
Comment:
characters left. If you paste in more than 1500 characters, it will be truncated. You cannot comment the same episode twice in a row. Discuss the issues - personal attacks against other posters will be deleted.
Answer 8 + 8 =

You can also discuss this episode in the Skeptoid Forum, hosted by the James Randi Educational Foundation.

Join the Skeptalk email discussion list.

Skeptoid book:
Now available!
 
Skeptoid: Critical Analysis of Pop Phenomena, by Brian Dunning
Watch Here Be Dragons, the 40-minute video introduction to critical thinking. Based on the Skeptoid podcast.
 
Skeptoid Widget
Newest

Spy Radio: Numbers Station
Skeptoid #107
July 1, 2008
Read | Listen (10:28)
King Tut's Curse!
Skeptoid #106
June 24, 2008
Read | Listen (10:43)
When People Talk Backwards
Skeptoid #105
June 17, 2008
Read | Listen (11:10)
Yet More Winning Listener Feedback
Skeptoid #104
June 10, 2008
Read | Listen (12:43)
Should You Take Your Vitamins?
Skeptoid #103
June 3, 2008
Read | Listen (10:12)
Newest
#1 -
The Detoxification Myth
Read | Listen
#2 -
An Evolution Primer for Creationists
Read | Listen
#3 -
Religion as a Moral Center
Read | Listen
#4 -
World Trade Center 7: The Lies Come Crashing Down
Read | Listen
#5 -
Apocalypse 2012
Read | Listen
#6 -
Super Sized Fast Food Phobia
Read | Listen
#7 -
Killing Faith: Deconstructionist Christians
Read | Listen
#8 -
New Age Energy
Read | Listen
[Valid RSS]
ZIP Code Database