Yule Logs

by Ashley Hamer Pritchard
December 23, 2025

This episode was sponsored by Gail and Jim Webber

Sponsor an episode!

You’ve probably heard of the yule log: maybe from Christmas carols, maybe from that fancy French chocolate cake, maybe from those fireplace videos on YouTube. But you probably don’t know where it comes from.

If you think you know the story — an ancient Norse tradition with magical properties that was handed down through millennia — you're not alone. But you're also completely wrong.

Just as yoga got rebranded with ancient mysticism and Ancient Chinese Medicine leaves out the part that was a 20th century invention, the yule log is a totally medieval tradition that people decided wasn’t ancient or exotic enough — and made up a story to fix that. Not once, but twice.

The Yule Log’s Alleged History

The Yule log’s backstory traditionally goes like this: in old Norse tradition, people would burn a massive log or tree trunk during the pagan festival of Yule to celebrate the rebirth of the sun during the winter solstice. The ceremony was believed to provide protection from evil spirits during the darkest parts of the year. The log was also supposed to represent vegetation spirits that helped ensure good crops and fertility during the coming 12 months. The fire itself was a form of sun magic, deployed when the sun was weakest to help it return to strength.

And in this pagan backstory, there were a lot of rules: The log had to be lit using a remnant saved from the previous year’s log, kept in the house all year to ward off evil spirits. When the fire burned down, people would save the ashes for fertilizer or spiritual protection. Sometimes it was carved to represent a woman, whose burning would keep misfortune away.

Over time, the story goes, the ritual of burning a log in the depths of winter was handed down from generation to generation, through the advent of Christianity until it found a place in modern Christmas traditions.

Rituals connecting us through millennia to people long dead are comforting. We like our traditions to be timeless — it gives them a sense of authenticity, of deep meaning.

But as far as we can tell, the tradition of the yule log is hundreds, not thousands of years old, and has nothing to do with pagans or Norse mythology. Scholars in the 1700s and 1800s looked at the superstitions that modern people attached to this tradition and assumed those beliefs came from an ancient pagan culture. As if that wasn’t enough, people in the 21st century then saw the word Yule, assumed it was Scandinavian, and turned the whole ritual into a Viking thing.

Where the Theory Came From

We can blame a few different people for starting the pagan rumor.

The 1700s saw the peak of antiquarianism, a forerunner to modern historical sciences, in which scholars would investigate the ancient world through texts and other materials. But a lot of it was just casual speculation.

The first antiquarian who started the pagan Yule log game of telephone was Henry Bourne. In the 1720s, he wrote about the yule log custom and included the innocuous line, "It hath, in all probability, been derived from the Saxons" — referring to the Germanic people who migrated to Britain in the 5th century to become the Anglo-Saxons, and who famously practiced paganism.

That’s it. "In all probability." His only evidence? A monk, Saint Bede, wrote about some mid-winter festivals followed by the Saxons, and Bourne speculated that was probably when they used the yule log.

50 years later, an antiquarian named John Brand speculated, in a footnote, that maybe the yule log was the winter counterpart to the pagan midsummer bonfire. Once again, with zero evidence.

Soon, these kinds of conjectures were formalized in the language of science. Around the turn of the 20th century, the Scottish anthropologist Sir James Frazer published The Golden Bough: A Study in Comparative Religion, an extremely influential book that tried to define the elements that all religious belief and scientific thought had in common. And most of it was based on vibes.

That was where the myth really got legs. Using the writing of those earlier scholars as evidence, he wrote:

In modern Christendom the ancient fire-festival of the winter solstice appears to survive... in the old custom of the Yule log... The custom was widespread in Europe, but seems to have flourished especially in England, France, and among the South Slavs; at least the fullest accounts of the custom come from these quarters. That the Yule log was only the winter counterpart of the midsummer bonfire, kindled within doors instead of in the open air on account of the cold and inclement weather of the season, was pointed out long ago by our English antiquary John Brand; and the view is supported by the many quaint superstitions attaching to the Yule log, superstitions which have no apparent connexion with Christianity but carry their heathen origin plainly stamped upon them.

In essence: The beliefs people attach to the Yule log don’t seem Christian, so they must be pagan.

Why Scholars Don’t Buy It

Frazer’s book on comparative religion was discredited a few years after it was published, though it had already done its damage. Meanwhile, other scholars were writing about why we have no real reason to believe the yule log is pagan.

Think about it: The yule log is essentially a big log burned in a fireplace. That’s how people heated their homes for centuries — there’s nothing special about that. The difference is that this log was particularly big, and it was associated with a bunch of different superstitions. Superstitions are also extremely common. Even for Christians.

Most importantly, though, there’s just no evidence that the practice is pagan.

In 1889, the German philosopher Alexander Tille pointed out that there is no record of the yule log in Britain before 1600. Nobody writing letters to loved ones about burning their yule log, no historians publishing about it, just silence.

And that’s not for lack of trying: especially in the few hundred years before that, there were a boatload of records: people recorded almost everything about their customs, even things as simple as how they decorated and what they ate.

In Germany, though, there are references to the custom dating back hundreds of years earlier to 1184 — which, while long ago, is still after paganism had mostly died out.

Scholars think medieval Germany is probably where the yule log got its start. It possibly spread through Flanders, the wealthy region in modern-day Brussels, northeastern France, and a bit of the Netherlands that acted as a merchant hub. By the 19th century, there’s evidence of the custom in France, the Italian Alps, Serbia, and most of Europe.

This is not what you’d expect of a millennia-old pagan practice — instead, this looks more like a medieval custom growing in popularity.

The Swedish scholar C.W. von Sydow had a simpler explanation: you need a fire burning all Christmas week, so you get a huge log. We make things special on Christmas — fancy china, decorations, Christmas carols. Why not a special log?

The Real Yule Log Tradition

So if the Yule log isn't ancient, what is it really?

The first British mention comes from poet Robert Herrick in the 1620s-1630s. He called it the 'Christmas log' — not the Yule log — and described cheering young men bringing it to the farmhouse, where the farmer's wife rewarded them with all the alcohol they could drink. He mentioned that people believed the log brought prosperity, that it was lit to music using a remnant from last year's log, and that keeping that remnant safe throughout the year would protect the house from evil.

These are the beliefs that antiquarian scholars thought were evidence of pagan roots. But more likely, it was just modern people having a little fun.

By the late 1600s, the custom had spread across Britain under different regional names, though it was missing from wood-scarce areas and places where Christmas wasn't celebrated.

And when I say "log," I’m not talking about something you could carry under your arm. These were enormous — big enough to fill a large hearth on their own. They often had to be dragged in by a team of several men or even horses. The goal was to keep it burning through all of Christmas Day, or sometimes little by little through all 12 days of Christmas.

The whole thing was festive and competitive. In eastern Somerset, a young man would ride the log as it was dragged home, and if he could stay on without being thrown off, he'd get mulled ale and hot cakes as a reward. Households competed to see who could get the biggest log — this was documented peasant behavior, the kind of one-upmanship that happened all the time in rural communities.

As for those magical associations Frazer was so interested in? They show up inconsistently — ashes for fertilizer, protection from witches, carvings to ward off misfortune. It's hard to prove these were original rather than grafted on later.

There was even a regional alternative in Devon and Somerset: bundles of ash stakes tied with bark bands. Every time a band burst in the fire, everyone got drinks and a toast. It doesn't appear in records until 1795. Both traditions died out in the late 1800s as farm labor decreased and old hearths disappeared.

But even though the tradition faded, the mythology kept growing. In fact, it grew in a completely new direction.

The Viking Invention

Remember how I said people invented an ancient backstory for the Yule log not once, but twice? Here's where the second invention comes in.

You've probably heard that the Yule log is a Viking tradition. If you Google it, you'll find plenty of websites declaring Vikings burned Yule logs. There's just one problem: there's no evidence for that.

Here's what actually happened. The word "Yule" itself IS Scandinavian — it comes from Old Norse jól, Swedish jul, and Danish juul. When Danes controlled parts of England in the 11th century, the word became popular English slang for Christmas. By the 13th century, it had spread to Scotland, where it became standard in everyday speech.

There WAS a Norse festival called Yule — a three-night winter solstice festival with sacrifices for good crops. But that doesn't mean they burned logs.

As I mentioned, the custom was originally called the "Christmas log," not the "Yule log." Even in other languages, it's still called some variation of "Christmas log" or "Christmas block." The name "Yule log" only shows up in English in the late 1600s, when "Yule" had simply become another word for Christmas in England — like how we say "Yuletide" today.

When Victorian scholars like Bourne and Frazer speculated about pagan origins, they said "Anglo-Saxon" or vaguely "European pagan." They never claimed it was specifically Norse or Viking. That connection doesn't appear in any of the old scholarship.

The Norse/Viking claim seems to be a thoroughly modern invention — probably from the 2000s and 2010s, when neo-paganism was booming and the Vikings were having a pop culture moment. Someone noticed that "Yule" was a Norse word, knew there was a Norse festival called Yule, and made the logical leap: if we call it a "Yule log," it must be a Norse tradition!

It's folk etymology for the internet age — websites cite each other until it seems true. Track down the sources and the Norse connection evaporates.

It’s two layers of invention: 18th-century scholars invented pagan origins based on vibes, then 21st-century internet culture invented a Viking origin based on a word.

The Yule Log Today

As for the Yule log itself? That chocolate cake is about as close as most of us get these days. The bûche de Noël — French for "Christmas log" — became popular in France in the 19th century, right around the time the actual tradition was fading. Today it's probably how most people under 50 know about Yule logs at all.

Well, that and Christmas episodes of Skeptoid.

By Ashley Hamer Pritchard