SKEPTOID BLOG:Should You Make a New Year's Resolution?January 1, 2016 There are a lot of reasons to be skeptical of New Year's resolutions, both from our collective personal experience and from what any number of published polls about resolution-keeping have consistently confirmed: that individuals likelywon'tstick to them, that they probablywillfall back into old habits, and that they probablywillmake themselves feel awful about it. And yet we keep making them. Humans have a fascination with the start of something new -- the first episode of a new television show, the first day of a new school year, the first film in a new Star Wars trilogy, etc. Marking beginnings (and the anniversary of beginnings) with hope for the future is just part of who we are. And so we continue, at the start of each year, to resolve to make this year better than last year in some small, meaningful way. So, should we make a New Year's resolution? The numbers are against us. However, there are ways of improving our odds of success, if we learn from what psychologists and behavioral scientists have discovered about resolutions and use that learning to our advantage. If we're going to go through with it again this year, we might as well do it right. In reality, a New Year's resolution is just a fancy name for goal setting. The basic psychology of goal setting is pretty standardized in the literature, though there are a thousand ways the science has been packaged and repackaged into self-help books, personal improvement blogs, and TED talks. This conversation with psychologist Kelly McGonigal has the nice spin on the question. For a longer read, just go browse Google Scholar for a couple hours. [Just watch the clock, or your dinner will burn as mine did.] In general, the collective research on goal setting reveals that resolutions must have the following qualities:
An even more meaningless resolution is "to eat healthier". Technically, one could eat an extra serving of vegetables a day while changing nothing else about their eating habits and achieve this one. Better to define some way to measure "healthier", like "I resolve to reduce my sodium intake to below 2,300mg a day" or "I resolve to only eat red meat twice a week." These are more open-ended goals, in that there's no stated point where you will stop limiting sodium or start eating red meat again (ideally you develop a habit and stick with it); but they also have quicker measures of victory, in that each day or week is an achievement unto itself. And best of all, that larger implied goal of "to eat healthier" is also accomplished. So go ahead and make a New year's resolution. Just make sure that, whether you make a resolution on January first or just resolve to set some life goal at any point in your year, that you're doing it wisely and with the best understanding of the psychology of goal-setting on your side. As for myself, I'm skipping the New Year's resolutions this time around. I already have a few goals I'm working on, and I see no good reason to add another to the list. @Skeptoid Media, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit |