The Cost of Not Vaccinating

vaccines-are-not-toxicInstead of finishing and posting a normal blog post this week, I wanted to share something that came across my social media feed thanks to the Anti-Vaccine Body Count page. While normally I would post about the statistics and science of how vaccines work and about their safety, sometimes using the same tactics as anti-vaccine, anti-science peddlers is effective in at least getting those on the fence to more closely examine their beliefs and hopefully the science.

Let me address some of the possible comments first. Yes, I know vaccines do occasionally cause an injury. Statistically, the chance of any permanent injury is so rare that you have a much better chance of being struck by lightning than you do getting permanently injured by a vaccine. However, there are many more people who are in danger of being harmed by the diseases they are designed to protect us from.

This brings me to [link and named removed by author]. Normally, I do not get too worked up by “open letters.” And while [Name removed] may not get every scientific detail correct, and I may not entirely agree with her idea of community responsibility, I rather enjoyed her use of appeal to emotion, the same strategy employed by anti-vaccination websites. She highlights the fears of a parent with a child who is immunocompromised. Modern medicine gives us the tools to help [Name removed] child make it to adulthood and live a full, happy, productive life. The rejection of modern science is putting [Name removed] child at greater risk of not making it to adulthood.

[Name removed] begins with the event that inspired her post:

Tonight, while enjoying a nice dinner, I got a call from the director of my son’s preschool. She was calling to tell me that they had made the decision to put my son in a different class because two children in the class he was supposed to be in have “opted out” of their vaccines. This may not sound like a big thing. He is still in the Tuesday-Thursday class, and since he doesn’t start school until next Tuesday, it’s not like he has to get readjusted to a whole new class. No harm, no foul. Actually, this is a big deal—a very big deal. You see, my son is immunocompromised. He has cancer. He was fully vaccinated and supporting the whole “herd immunity” thing before his cancer diagnosis, but that darn chemo wiped out his immunity to the communicable diseases against which he had already been vaccinated.

Read the [link and named removed by author]. Thank you [name removed] for allowing it to be shared.

Update: It is sad that it appears the author was being attacked by some anti-vaccine people and had to close down the public access to her post and page. I am going to attempt to contact her to see if we can share her entire post here. 

I also want to note before the post was removed and her page closed down, there was a history on her page. While it is not impossible to create an extensive fake profile with a history on Facebook, I didn’t feel it necessary to investigate further. Why? Because I am not presenting this as proof. I wouldn’t ever present an anecdote as proof (like anti-science sites do). Instead, I wanted to provide an example in narrative form which demonstrates one of the populations left vulnerable by the loss of herd immunity. The purpose of this post means the level of fact-checking is not set as high. In fact, even if it was entirely fabricated, it doesn’t change its validity for this purpose. I have family and friends who have been affected by cancer. They do lose their immunity due to chemotherapy. They needed the family to be vaccinated so they could still enjoy get-togethers. This is not a unique story – but just an example of why your vaccine choice does affect others.

About Eric Hall

My day job is teaching physics at the University of Minnesota, Rochester. I write about physics, other sciences, politics, education, and whatever else interests or concerns me. I am always working to be rational and reasonable, and I am always willing to improve my knowledge and change my mind when presented with new evidence.
This entry was posted in Health and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to The Cost of Not Vaccinating

  1. Gordon Ward says:

    Hi – the link to Alex’s post doesn’t work 🙁

  2. J. Y. says:

    The links don’t work!

  3. VASA says:

    Alex Pomadoni does not exist. The story you are referring to is 100% fabricated! Do your homework!

  4. JP says:

    Alex Pomadoni does NOT exist.

  5. JP says:

    This article is written by Alex Pomadoni.

    Alex Pomadoni does not exist. All articles written by this “person” are;
    1. Made up;
    2. Funded by Pharma
    3. Created purely to instill fear and panic.

    • Joe says:

      She has a facebook she is a real person just a mother not a famous author I bet if you googled my name you would find me either that doesn’t mean I don’t exist.

    • A friend says:

      She does, she left social media because of the severe harrassment by anti-vaxers. I am only allowed to do this anonymously for the safety of her family

  6. grumppa says:

    I would expect that the anti-vax haters found her and attacked her and her child. Because hate is all they have.

  7. TorchWood says:

    I appreciate the validity of the emotional appeal to the better angels of their nature in the anti-vaccination people.

    However, these people aren’t concerned about exposing their own children to deadly infection, so I think that they aren’t motivated to care about your children either.

    Your best course is to be vigorously pro-active about protecting your child yourself. Sad, but safer for your child.

  8. A site called Skeptoid should cast a skeptical eye on everything it considers. You have conspicuously failed to do any fact-checking for this article when it comes to pro-vaccination claims.

    • Ruckus says:

      And where are your counter-claims and citations?

    • Eric Hall says:

      The point of posting this wasn’t to make it some long, factual statement on vaccines and herd immunity. If it is real or fake, it serves as an example of who needs herd immunity. IN the post, I fully admit it is an anecdote and not data. I fully admit it is not “proof” of anything.

      The level of fact checking I do for my articles roughly matches the level of claim I am making. Here I was simply using a story as a way to explain a concept. It serves that purpose.

  9. John VonBokel says:

    Alex Pomadoni does exist. She probably just didn’t make that post public, or reverted it to private after receiving some negative reactions.

  10. Bill says:

    I like the ‘Thank you, [name removed], for allowing it to be shared’. The ultimate in unplanned irony.

  11. John says:

    If a parents refuse to allow their children to be vaccinated, they need to home school them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *